2019-20 BPA Twilight Struggle Tournament — Round 10
Start Date: 2020-03-24 End Date: TBA
- Name in bold font indicates victor.
- Player listed in first column bids first.
- Player shown in purple font is an Eliminator.
- Asterisk on Game number indicates a Note of Interest following the table.
- 1 vs 2 decides 1st and 2nd place
- 3 vs 4 decides 3rd and 4th place.
- Allan’s AAR:
- The Final was a match between defending PBeM champion Aran Warszawski (USSR) and reigning Caesar Allan Jiang (USA+2), the only two players with only one loss after 9 rounds of play. The finalists had previously faced off dozens of times in the civilization building game Through the Ages, but this was only their second game of Twilight Struggle.
- The game started with a US headline of Asia Scoring. A coup and counter-coup left 4 US influence in Iran. The USSR focused on building domination in Asia, while the US spread in the Middle East before giving up Nasser. The USSR then equalized the Middle East before playing Mideast Scoring, while the US took France to end the Turn.
- In Turn 2, the USSR headlined Socialist Governments and immediately played Europe Scoring at a tie. The rest of the turn was an early rush for the midwar regions. The US played into Angola and Colombia at DEFCON 3, and this gambit worked as the USSR coup in Angola rolled a 1 and left the country without any influence. This limited the effectiveness of De-Stalinization, and at the end of the turn both superpowers were about equal in all midwar regions, while the Middle East swung to the Containment-boosted US.
- In Turn 3, the USSR couped Angola successfully this time and achieved domination in Africa. The US entered North Korea with its last action. At the end of the early war, the score (+1VP) and board position were both close.
- In Turn 4, the USSR opened with a coup in Brazil, rolling just a 2 but was able to take it later as the US opted to take North Korea and pressed with Asia Scoring in hand. The USSR did not have enough operations to be able to fight back, and even worse, had both Europe and Mideast Scoring. The US scored domination in all three early war regions, and suddenly was up to +18VP after sending a Man in Space. The USSR responded by launching an Earth Satellite to prevent an automatic victory, but gave up Nuclear Subs as its last action. This allowed the US to take Zaire and a dominant position in Africa.
- Turn 5 headlines were Lone Gunman and Africa Scoring. Lone Gunman allowed the USSR to coup Nigeria and again prevent automatic victory. The USSR attempted to take control of South America by realigning Venezuela at +2 (with Junta) and then +1, but found little cooperation with the dice: seven realignments there produced a net gain of just two influence. The US repeatedly reentered Venezuela from its small presence in Brazil, a lingering effect of the low coup in Brazil in Turn 4. The USSR then turned its attention to Central America but did not have domination while playing Central America Scoring. The US broke Soviet control of Brazil with its last action.
- Turn 6 headlines were Missile Envy (drawing Flower Power) and OAS Founded. The USSR couped Venezuela but was only able to clear all influence. This allowed the US to retake it with the forced play of Missile Envy and play South America Scoring at a draw. With all six major regions scored, both superpowers sought to improve their positions around the board in anticipation of the reshuffle. The score was +14VP at the end of this Turn.
- Turn 7 headlines were The Cambridge Five and Kitchen Debates. Knowing that the US held Southeast Asia and no other Scoring card, the USSR started by improving its position in that region. The US evented Nixon Plays the China Card to bring the score to +18VP. The USSR couped Venezuela successfully, but it was too little, too late as the US scored exactly 2 more VP with a reshuffled Alliance for Progress to achieve automatic victory.
- The dice played a major role in the outcome of this game. The US decisively won the T1 coup war in Iran, and benefited greatly from low rolls during USSR coups in Angola (T2), Brazil (T4), and Venezuela (T6), as well as the T5 realignments in Venezuela. On the whole, the cards were relatively even between the superpowers, but the timing of the scoring cards favored the US. Other big swings were the T4 USSR hand (few usable operations and scoring cards for two US-dominated regions) and the T7 US hand (seven cards that could directly change the VP track).
- Aran’s additional comments: (lightly edited)
- Another take about the factors of games are cards: USSR had Decolonization and De-Stalinazation, which are a big boost to USSR. On the other hand US got a perfect Containment, with no 4-op cards in hand to waste.
- Also interesting, no Brush war or ABM treaty in the game.
- USSR got also Junta and Liberation Theology, but it was balanced with Colonial rear guard and voice of America.
- USSR held more scoring cards, which are generally bad. Especially the timing of the scoring cards was very favorable to the US.
- Overall hard to say who gained on cards, I think a small advantage to USSR, wasn’t enough with too many bad rolls. and a great play from US.
- One last note is that the board was about even at the end, which left US with a very strong position, even if there was no auto- victory at 20VP (especially as cards were a bit favoring US, as is normal at this stage of the game.)
SU = 1 (74) US = 1 (67)
| Game | Name | Power | Name | Power | Bid | Type/Turn | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Allan J 1L | US | vs | Aran W 1L | SU | 2 | VP/7 |
| 2 | Michael S 2L | US | vs | Tony R 2L | SU | 2 | CON/9 |
Game Notes:
#2: T9: conceded.